So I have owned many different coolers. I went based on what my, my friends, and online reviews said, and decided to try out the Otterbox line. It is hands down WAY better than pretty much all the others that I have tried. It continuously out performs, all of my friends' (and my old) Yeti in ice retention. Normally by several days. The only ones that I have seen that come close are a friends Canyon Outfitters, Orca, and a Pelican Elite.
Ice retention is amazing. Far better than most. Design it pretty decent. I would prefer a cooler this size to have wheels. The sticky feet are insane. Empty you have a very hard time pushing it into a truck bed. The grips are very comfortable. I like it so much I bought another.
I even ordered a skin for it to customize it.