As a guide unfortunately I am a harsh critic when it comes to gear. The DSG products we bought are fantastic. My wife wore them this hunting season in a variety of weather conditions. She stayed warm and comfy all the time. We realize a breathable and windproof product is hard to make. Walking to and from the stands they were confortable. The pockets were placed well and worked well. The padded knees are a great accessory for stalking and crawling!