The coat is lightweight, windproof, and waterproof all of which are great qualities. The waist gaiter is nice too. I do notice that my arms get cold quickly when wearing this coat. Seems like there is no insulation in the arms. It isn't quite warm enough to stand out on the ice all day, but it would be great for fishing in a shelter. It is also a great coat if you are moving a lot like shoveling snow. The coat looks great and the flotation is a plus for those out on the ice. I would like it to be warmer. I compared it wearing the same clothes with my old heavy ice suit and the cold feeling in the arms happened pretty quick with the Avid. My old suit is heavy but warm. I was looking for something lighter. There is definitely a time and place for this coat, but standing on the ice all day in the elements isn't it. I would recommend it for lighter use.